Women delivered the presidency to Obama with our votes. In a rambling op-ed at the Boston Globe’s website, Ellen Goodman, provides the numbers that show how women in swing states made the difference. Goodman’s point was that women vote for agenda, not gender. But the way she made her point is far more telling. She devotes the majority of her piece to unnecessary Palin-bashing, including ridiculing the way the Governor speaks and, of course, what would a mainstream media piece be without bringing up the clothes and restating the unsubstantiated rumors and lies allegedely coming from the McCain campaign, about Palin. Perhaps Goodman missed that MSNBC had to apologize yesterday for their role in failing to verify information and instead rushing it out to the airwaves, thus spreading out and out lies…
Goodman’s op-ed is a classic example of how women tear down other women, even when there is no need and it serves no purpose.
I left the following comments on the Globe website:
I came across your piece and was interested by the title. Yet when I started reading it, I had to look up again to be sure I’d followed the correct link. I studied journalism and know that a well constructed story has as its lead its most powerful piece of information. If your story is about agenda, not gender, you missed the mark.
Instead we are treated to yet another round of Palin-bashing that rambles on for four paragraphs, in case, I guess, we didn’t “get it” that you voted for Obama and don’t like Palin.
But when you FINALLY made your point, buried in the middle of the piece, it was a very interesting one. I find it terrible disappointing to see that so many women are still throwing their votes away, on candidates who aren’t going to do a thing to help us, unless there is a gun to their head of some metaphorical kind. Obama remained silent when the two women running against his ticket were bashed and slashed by the media, and in Senator Clinton’s case, by her own Party. He knew he could do that because he knew women were more inclined to tear down another woman than expect a man to stand up for sexism. And you who voted for him proved that right.
Your op-ed, perhaps unintentionally, was the perfect example of your story’s theme – agenda over gender. You embody in your own words exactly why women are underrepresented in every area of life. It is that need to tear down another woman unnecessarily, to ridicule and diminish someone, while trying to elevate yourself.
I do commend you for closing with an important point about the historic nature of Palin’s run – how she has transformed the landscape for the Republican party. It’s just unfortunate that you had to bring up the clothes again as an ending since, as everyone knows who has been paying attention this week, she didn’t ask for them and does not possess them.
Perhaps the day will come when all women, you included, Ms. Goodman, will realize that while we snipe at each other, and hold each other back, men continue to dominate politics and run our country. And it may be another 24 years before any major Party puts another woman on its ticket. That is nothing for women to be proud of, in my opinion.